Most writers who blog do so to tell other writers the do's and don'ts of writing. Me, on the other hand. I ask what to do. I just have to be different. Besides, I am well aware that I am in no position to give instruction on writing. That would be one of those examples of the blind leading the blind. I guess that I just hope to get a little input from my fellow writers and maybe I can inspire someone who is going through the same struggles I am, as I fumble my way through the writing process.
So, what's the problem today? Didn't I just yesterday announce that I had finished my 3rd draft? It's true. I did that. And like a true writer, I am already questioning it twenty-four hours later.
My issue is with the way my book starts. It starts like books generally tend to start. The main character is introduced and described and the setting is introduced. It's a girl getting ready for school... But, apparently (according to some) this is the WRONG way to start a book. From what I have recently been told, it is juvenile and totally old school to start a book at the "beginning." The experts say that a fiction novel should not start at the beginning. But, instead it should begin in the middle of an action scene. The thinking behind this is, that the reader needs to be engaged right off the bat. Readers today have short attention spans and they require more than a simple introduction at the beginning of a story. Long gone are the days of, "Once upon a time," so it seems...
I have mixed feelings about this. As a writer, I understand the need to grab a reader's attention early on in a story. However, as a reader I have to say that I am not a fan of books that begin with the MC already in the middle of a conflict. I have no idea who the person is. I don't know anything about them other than their name. The fact that they are dangling from a cliff or have been bitten by a snake is more confusing than it is exciting, when you don't know the person involved. (this is just my opinion)
So, that leaves me wondering... Do I scrap my first chapter and rewrite it to make it more exciting? Is it more important that the MC be thrust into a dilemma then it is to let the reader know who he/she is? I am very torn. I want to make my book the highest caliber possible before releasing it to the masses. So, which is the right way? I am stuck pondering.
So, what's the problem today? Didn't I just yesterday announce that I had finished my 3rd draft? It's true. I did that. And like a true writer, I am already questioning it twenty-four hours later.
My issue is with the way my book starts. It starts like books generally tend to start. The main character is introduced and described and the setting is introduced. It's a girl getting ready for school... But, apparently (according to some) this is the WRONG way to start a book. From what I have recently been told, it is juvenile and totally old school to start a book at the "beginning." The experts say that a fiction novel should not start at the beginning. But, instead it should begin in the middle of an action scene. The thinking behind this is, that the reader needs to be engaged right off the bat. Readers today have short attention spans and they require more than a simple introduction at the beginning of a story. Long gone are the days of, "Once upon a time," so it seems...
I have mixed feelings about this. As a writer, I understand the need to grab a reader's attention early on in a story. However, as a reader I have to say that I am not a fan of books that begin with the MC already in the middle of a conflict. I have no idea who the person is. I don't know anything about them other than their name. The fact that they are dangling from a cliff or have been bitten by a snake is more confusing than it is exciting, when you don't know the person involved. (this is just my opinion)
So, that leaves me wondering... Do I scrap my first chapter and rewrite it to make it more exciting? Is it more important that the MC be thrust into a dilemma then it is to let the reader know who he/she is? I am very torn. I want to make my book the highest caliber possible before releasing it to the masses. So, which is the right way? I am stuck pondering.
So sorry that you are second guessing yourself.
ReplyDeleteYou were so happy yesterday and 24 hours later...you are doubting yourself.
You are the author...WRITE YOUR STORY!!
That is all!
OpinionsToGo
I'm with you all the way on this one. To give you an idea, I actually cut 25k words worth of introduction on my book.
ReplyDeleteWhile in my case it certainly made the book better, it slowed me to snails pace for a couple months.
I ended up taking the five to ten elements that "needed" to be in the book and dispersed it throughout the remaining portion.
OpinionsToGo has the right idea. You really do need to write your story. Isn't that why we write?
Think about it like grammar. There are basic rules writers should follow, but knowing when to break those rules is just as important. The same goes with story construction.
The self-doubt issue is tough. I believe it is part of what makes us better writers. If you were satisfied with everything you did there wouldn't be any improvement. Only experience will tell you when you've worked on something enough, and maybe not even then. :)
Sorry for the long comment, lots of coffee this morning!
Thanks to you both for the kind words. I know it might seem like I am beating myself up all the time. I assure you it is not the case. I am, however, trying to be candid and honest about my questions and struggles as I venture through uncharted territory. I love reading your comments!
ReplyDeleteGood point, Sheryl. I would like to figure out a good way to do this. It is a bit complicated, though. I have 2 MC's and they each have their own protagonist and conflicts along with what they experience together. I want to hook the reader, I am just not exactly sure how at this point. Thanks so much for the comment. I will keep working!
ReplyDelete@Paul. Your blog post may or may not have inspired me to write this. I confess nothing. LOL.
ReplyDelete