Skip to main content

Plotter or Panster?

I did it! I can officially say that I wrote a novel. I am playing the waiting game as my IT guy plays around with some formatting and works his computer magic, getting it all spiffy and what-not. So, while I wait I am doing a bit of reflecting on all of the things I learned while writing my first book. "You've come a long way, baby," as they say.

One of the things I learned is that writers often classify themselves as either a plotter or a panster. Before taking on this project, I had never heard of such a thing. If you aren't familiar with those terms, a plotter is someone who plans their whole book with outlines and lists before actually sitting down to write. A panster is someone who flies by the seat of their pants. They don't plan; they just sit down and write.

I was watching the television show, American Chopper last night with my husband and it occurred to me that the two main characters of that show are perfect examples of both a plotter and a panster. If you are familiar with the show, then you will totally be able to get the concept of these terms when I tell you that Paul Senior is a plotter and Paul Junior is a panster.

So, what am I? I guess I am somewhere in the middle, if that is possible. I am more plotter than panster, but I am still a little of both. What that means is, I make a plan before I write, but often find myself deviating from said plan.

When I decided to write my book, I sat down with a pad of paper and a pencil and I started devising my plan of action. I made lists of my characters by name. I listed their astrological signs, character traits, birth order, physical appearance, etc. I mapped out their family trees and devised their family dynamic.

Next, I started outlining. I hit the high points first and then filled in the middle. And then I sat down to write.

I found that I added several things that weren't included in the initial plan and I also left out some of the parts I had pre-planned. (Granted, I ended up cutting a vast majority of the extra stuff later) But, what did I know? I had never written a book before.

I guess if I have to pick one or the other, I would have to classify myself as a plotter. It makes sense. I am a list maker by habit. I have a need to be organized. What about you?

Comments

  1. Hi Jessica,
    When I started to write my crime novel, because I plan every other aspect of my life I expected to be able to plan it too. But I found I couldn't and for a while thought I simply wasn't up to the task! Then I sat down and just wrote. I had a beginning and an end and my technique evolved that I would plan a few chapters ahead, write them, then plan a few more, and so on. After a while I relaxed into it and this technique has continued to work for me. I'm 'polishing' my novel now in readiness for sending out in the New Year, and intend to tackle my second in the same way.
    The best writing hint I ever read was to remember that a writer doesn't have to get her work right first time, unlike a brain surgeon.
    My first visit to your blog. Interesting content and I love your wallpaper.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Congratulations on finishing your novel.

    I'm more a plotter than a pantser but it's good to change your mind and let your characters tell you what they want to do.

    All the best with it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Congratulations! When can can we expect to see your novel?

    I'm definitely a plotter.

    I've tried both methods - I once wrote a brilliant first chapter, only to realise I had no idea what to do with the characters I'd created. It's still sitting there on my computer. Maybe one day...

    By contrast, my thriller, The Power Behind The Throne, was fully plotted from start to finish before I wrote a word. The outline ran to 10,000 words - about ten per cent of the finished book.

    I had every scene worked out. But the magic happened when I began to write those scenes... almost every time, a 'surprise' happened - which is to say, something cropped up that I had not anticipated, and its inclusion made for a better book.

    It's a bit like Fight Club. The only rule is that there IS no rule! I have friends who say that if they adopted my creative process, they would have done so much preparation they wouldn't want to write the novel.

    But as my books take me (at least) a year to write, I want to be sure I have a sustainable story, with a clear beginning, middle and an end before I commit.

    For me, that's telling a story with a useful safety net while I'm tip-toeing across the chasm that separates the first sentence to the last.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for the comments! I really enjoy finding out how other writers do their stuff. I find it so interesting.

    To Janet: thanks for stopping by my blog. I am glad you like the wallpaper. I get a lot of compliments on it. :)

    To Pete: thank you for the congrats and also for stopping by. I appreciate it!

    To Sally: it sounds like you and I had similar expereinces writing. It is good to plan, but also important to go with the flow.

    Look for my debut novel, Small Town Hero in Amazon's Kindle store on Monday Dec 12!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Past Wrongs

Keather and I got to talking about people from school and somehow we got onto the subject of times boys were mean to us or creepy or disrespected us in some way. As it turns out, we both could name several examples of guys being assholes in one way or another. As a grown woman who now understands the seriousness of, " boys being boys ," and how it justifies the rape culture in this country, I look back on those experiences and the memories infuriate me. Something has to be done to teach boys about consent and that, raging hormones or not, they cannot just do whatever they want. I WILL teach my son these things. I've already given one terrible example of a couple of guys being creepy toward me as an adult. And, I want to put down a few more examples of times things like that have happened. I don't really think about it much, but as my children reach their teen years and as I see things between kids on the track team, I am reminded of the importance of respect and bo...

Track Banquet

Last night was the official end to the season It was an interesting year of ups and downs with the absence of Coach Hassett. I am curious to see what happens going forward, with the coaching situation. Personally, I feel like I really grew as a coach this year. I have really embraced the pole vault as a wonderful challenge. I intend to continue to learn how to be a better coach and I know that I was able to help kids and actually teach them in a way I was not able to last year. I am looking forward to learning more about how to teach the more advanced vaulting techniques. I will read and study and plan for some off season workouts. I've got three kids who want to take it to the next level, who do not have a winter sport. So, we will work on pole vault by drilling, doing weight training and strength building exercises. It's pretty exciting and I look forward to seeing how they progress into next season. The banquet was nice. Long, but nice. I was surprised by the fa...

Memorial Weekend 2026

  It was an interesting week leading up to the holiday weekend. A lot happened. The storm ripped through and caused a bunch of damage and power outages. NASCAR driver Kyle Busch died unexpectedly from sepsis. Alec's mother in law died of cancer. It was a pretty terrible week. The holiday weekend was a cold and/or rainy one, with the exception of Monday. We only ended up racing on Friday night at I96. We drove down to Butler only for them to cancel an hour later, and they canceled Crystal on Sunday because of a big line of storms in the early afternoon. So, we spent the weekend at home.  Uncle Doug did come over on Friday and tilled up my very large garden plot. I worked hard between rain showers, to get as much planted as I could. I was able to work all afternoon on Friday, and parts of Sunday and Monday. Saturday was too rainy. I am glad we got the rain, for the plants and seeds, but I did have to work around it. The garden has a lot in it, but it looks really sparse right no...