I read three books this week. I have never done that before in my entire life! And one thing I noticed is that being a writer has changed how I read. The change didn't come all at once, but progressed gradually. Before writing seriously, I was blissfully unaware of anything besides a good story. Things did change.
First, I couldn't read anything without seeing it as an editor would. I couldn't enjoy what I was reading because I was in a proofreading state of mind. Eventually, I was able to lighten up and once again read for pleasure. Although, I still have a bit of a critical eye. I have the ability to spot inconsistencies, typos and repetition in a way I never was able to before. Excessive adverbs stick out like a sore thumb! Where am I going with this? I'll tell you...
First, let me start by saying that I am not a fan of blog posts that are book reviews. I like to form my own opinion about something I read, and I get bored by reading these types of posts. (no offense if you often post reviews. I still like you as a person) So, this will not be a review, per say. It is more of an observation on my part.
The last book in the three I read this week was called, The Wedding Gift by Kathleen McKenna. It was on the list of Free books available in Kindle Edition, so I decided to give it a chance.
It's a first person narrative about this teenage bride who is gifted a haunted house by her bitchy mother-in-law. The concept sounded interesting enough. And it didn't disappoint in that respect. The character development was good and so was the pace. It was a fun read as far as the storyline was concerned. I cruised through the book in a day and a half, able to overlook the obvious problems because it was a free book. But, boy were there problems! People's names were spelled differently throughout the book, for instance Charlie was sometimes Charley. The MC named Leeanne was a southern girl who's voice was incredibly stereotypical and she must have said, "To be strictly honest," fifty-five times throughout the book.
There were incredible amounts of repetition in the story as well as far more showing than telling. The misuse of words leads me to think the editing was done using spellcheck, instead of a critical eye. There were some inconsistencies in the story and the writing on the whole just wasn't that good. But like I said... it was free.
I felt compelled to write a review on Amazon about my experience to the effect that I felt the story had great promise and so did the author. I just didn't feel the book was ready for publication. There was still work to be done. And that's when I discovered that this book, The Wedding Gift wasn't a self-published author's first attempt at an e-book. This book has been traditionally published! Not only that, but with the free promotional period over, the Kindle edition actually costs $7.99! Paperback is also available for $14.99. I couldn't believe it. See for yourself. http://www.amazon.com/The-Wedding-Gift-ebook/dp/B005TXZ6XE/ref=sr_1_2?s=digital-text&ie=UTF8&qid=1325622225&sr=1-2
The book was published by some company called, "Bell Bridge Books." At first I thought maybe McKenna had invented the name of a Publishing company to make the book look more professional. But, upon further investigation, I'll be damned if it isn't an actual company! Here's their website, http://www.bellebooks.com/shopcontent.asp?type=Our%20Authors
So, I have to ask... how did a publisher allow such a mediocre story to be available to the public? That book has a marketing budget! I don't fault the author in this one bit. Someone told her that her book was as good as it could be. (untrue as that is) They should have done better by her. The book needed one more really solid edit at the very least. The book has potential. But it is NOT the best it could have been. And it is NOT worth $14.99. It is not worth $7.99. Not by a long shot.
I guess that just goes to show you that just because something is "traditionally published" doesn't guarantee it is of a higher quality than what Indie authors have to offer.
First, I couldn't read anything without seeing it as an editor would. I couldn't enjoy what I was reading because I was in a proofreading state of mind. Eventually, I was able to lighten up and once again read for pleasure. Although, I still have a bit of a critical eye. I have the ability to spot inconsistencies, typos and repetition in a way I never was able to before. Excessive adverbs stick out like a sore thumb! Where am I going with this? I'll tell you...
First, let me start by saying that I am not a fan of blog posts that are book reviews. I like to form my own opinion about something I read, and I get bored by reading these types of posts. (no offense if you often post reviews. I still like you as a person) So, this will not be a review, per say. It is more of an observation on my part.
The last book in the three I read this week was called, The Wedding Gift by Kathleen McKenna. It was on the list of Free books available in Kindle Edition, so I decided to give it a chance.
It's a first person narrative about this teenage bride who is gifted a haunted house by her bitchy mother-in-law. The concept sounded interesting enough. And it didn't disappoint in that respect. The character development was good and so was the pace. It was a fun read as far as the storyline was concerned. I cruised through the book in a day and a half, able to overlook the obvious problems because it was a free book. But, boy were there problems! People's names were spelled differently throughout the book, for instance Charlie was sometimes Charley. The MC named Leeanne was a southern girl who's voice was incredibly stereotypical and she must have said, "To be strictly honest," fifty-five times throughout the book.
There were incredible amounts of repetition in the story as well as far more showing than telling. The misuse of words leads me to think the editing was done using spellcheck, instead of a critical eye. There were some inconsistencies in the story and the writing on the whole just wasn't that good. But like I said... it was free.
I felt compelled to write a review on Amazon about my experience to the effect that I felt the story had great promise and so did the author. I just didn't feel the book was ready for publication. There was still work to be done. And that's when I discovered that this book, The Wedding Gift wasn't a self-published author's first attempt at an e-book. This book has been traditionally published! Not only that, but with the free promotional period over, the Kindle edition actually costs $7.99! Paperback is also available for $14.99. I couldn't believe it. See for yourself. http://www.amazon.com/The-Wedding-Gift-ebook/dp/B005TXZ6XE/ref=sr_1_2?s=digital-text&ie=UTF8&qid=1325622225&sr=1-2
The book was published by some company called, "Bell Bridge Books." At first I thought maybe McKenna had invented the name of a Publishing company to make the book look more professional. But, upon further investigation, I'll be damned if it isn't an actual company! Here's their website, http://www.bellebooks.com/shopcontent.asp?type=Our%20Authors
So, I have to ask... how did a publisher allow such a mediocre story to be available to the public? That book has a marketing budget! I don't fault the author in this one bit. Someone told her that her book was as good as it could be. (untrue as that is) They should have done better by her. The book needed one more really solid edit at the very least. The book has potential. But it is NOT the best it could have been. And it is NOT worth $14.99. It is not worth $7.99. Not by a long shot.
I guess that just goes to show you that just because something is "traditionally published" doesn't guarantee it is of a higher quality than what Indie authors have to offer.
Comments
Post a Comment