I love me some Huffington Post. I find that of all of the news outlets, I flock to their site most often. I find their opinions and knowledge pertaining to the business of books to be foreword and unbiased. I also happen to think that they hit the nail on the head nine times out of ten.
Today's BIG STORY on HuffBooks is called "Should YA Books Be Given Ratings?" Be sure to check it out if you have the time. It is thought provoking.
So, as a writer of YA fiction, what are my feelings on this subject? Should the books be censored, or at the very least rated?
I think this is a slippery slope. You start throwing around the word CENSORSHIP and panties all over the country are instantly in a bunch. And, it really doesn't matter to some people why you are bringing it up. They just apparently loathe the word in general. I happen to have a dog in the fight. So, I guess I have a right and maybe even a responsibility to voice my opinion on the subject.
It seems like the hot ticket right now is everything YA. And, some authors are pushing the envelope with their content to try and score the big audience. This has some groups up in arms because, don't we as adults have a responsibility to the youth of the world to spoon feed them stories with high morals and positive messages?
Okay, I understand that viewpoint. But, the truth of the matter is, teens like to read stories they can relate to. And, unfortunately, things like drug use, premarital sex, pregnancy, rape, abuse, violence and suicide are a part of their world. To think otherwise is naive. It doesn't mean all of those things should be graphically detailed in every book, but they certainly shouldn't be off limits.
So, what's the answer to this? Should there be a rating system to warn parents about a book's subject matter? I'm not totally against it, but I think there is a simpler solution.
The problem is, the YA genre covers a wide age range. The exact target ages are different based on who you ask, but you can ballpark it at about the thirteen to nineteen range. There is a HUGE difference between a thirteen year old and a nineteen year old and they are rarely going to be interested in the same content.
Holy cow, when I was thirteen, I had just experienced my first period and I had to ask my friend to ask a boy if he liked me. At nineteen, I was married and had my own place. You see? BIG DIFFERENCE!
My solution to this problem is that there needs to be a genre created that exists between middle grade an young adult. It could be for readers age twelve to fifteen, or something. This would keep writers and publishers from having to devise a ratings system and would also keep them from every having to utter the dreaded C word. It seems so simple to me.
YA currently encompasses too broad of a target audience, in my opinion. The jump in maturity from age thirteen to nineteen is far too vast for them to be lumped into the same... well, anything really. You don't see many thirteen year olds hanging out with nineteen year olds. And if you do, chances are, they are up to no good.
How do you feel about it? Should the YA books be censored? Should they be rated? Chime in!
Today's BIG STORY on HuffBooks is called "Should YA Books Be Given Ratings?" Be sure to check it out if you have the time. It is thought provoking.
So, as a writer of YA fiction, what are my feelings on this subject? Should the books be censored, or at the very least rated?
I think this is a slippery slope. You start throwing around the word CENSORSHIP and panties all over the country are instantly in a bunch. And, it really doesn't matter to some people why you are bringing it up. They just apparently loathe the word in general. I happen to have a dog in the fight. So, I guess I have a right and maybe even a responsibility to voice my opinion on the subject.
It seems like the hot ticket right now is everything YA. And, some authors are pushing the envelope with their content to try and score the big audience. This has some groups up in arms because, don't we as adults have a responsibility to the youth of the world to spoon feed them stories with high morals and positive messages?
Okay, I understand that viewpoint. But, the truth of the matter is, teens like to read stories they can relate to. And, unfortunately, things like drug use, premarital sex, pregnancy, rape, abuse, violence and suicide are a part of their world. To think otherwise is naive. It doesn't mean all of those things should be graphically detailed in every book, but they certainly shouldn't be off limits.
So, what's the answer to this? Should there be a rating system to warn parents about a book's subject matter? I'm not totally against it, but I think there is a simpler solution.
The problem is, the YA genre covers a wide age range. The exact target ages are different based on who you ask, but you can ballpark it at about the thirteen to nineteen range. There is a HUGE difference between a thirteen year old and a nineteen year old and they are rarely going to be interested in the same content.
Holy cow, when I was thirteen, I had just experienced my first period and I had to ask my friend to ask a boy if he liked me. At nineteen, I was married and had my own place. You see? BIG DIFFERENCE!
My solution to this problem is that there needs to be a genre created that exists between middle grade an young adult. It could be for readers age twelve to fifteen, or something. This would keep writers and publishers from having to devise a ratings system and would also keep them from every having to utter the dreaded C word. It seems so simple to me.
YA currently encompasses too broad of a target audience, in my opinion. The jump in maturity from age thirteen to nineteen is far too vast for them to be lumped into the same... well, anything really. You don't see many thirteen year olds hanging out with nineteen year olds. And if you do, chances are, they are up to no good.
How do you feel about it? Should the YA books be censored? Should they be rated? Chime in!
Comments
Post a Comment