The idea of what makes someone a good writer is subjective, like most things. This is something I think about frequently. I have mixed feelings on the subject and I am interested to know how others feel. What is it that makes someone a great writer?
Is it all about beautiful prose?
To me, there is nothing more moving than a song with beautiful lyrics. You know as well as I do that there are great songwriters and then there are people who will use ridiculous words simply because they rhyme. Sometimes, they use the same word twice in a row because they can't find one that rhymes. Have you ever noticed that?
Beautiful music is one thing, beautiful poetry takes it to a whole other level. At least, to me.
My favorite songwriters are the likes of:
Florence Welch (Florence and the Machine)
Chris Cornell (Soundgarden, Audioslave, Temple of the Dog)
Roger Hodgson (Supertramp)
Fiona Apple
Fleetwood Mac (Lindsay Buckingham and Stevie Nicks)
There is certainly something to be said for beautiful prose.
But, is it everything?
Some will say that it is. Writers who can wax poetic like that are the epitome of great writers.
But, what about the story? How about what it takes to pull stories like Star Wars out of thin air? Just as there is something to be said for word usage, there is also something to be said for imagination.
I idolize the writers who write stories that take place in another time or on a different world or in another dimension. The art of creating something completely original is where it's at! I was so blown away by the movie The Matrix because the idea was so original. It was so fresh and so unlike anything I had ever seen before. I love that!
Personally, I happen to be far more entertained by a story that is unique and imaginative than I am by a story that is mediocre and predictable but beautifully written.
So, what makes someone a great writer? Is it someone who can think up amazing ideas and plot lines? Or is it someone who can string together words in beautiful fashion? I guess the perfect writer would be both. But, how often could that possibly happen?
Perhaps I am trying to compare apples to oranges. Maybe you can't compare the two because they are completely different aspects of writing. That's entirely possible. But, I happen to think the best writers are the ones who come up with the new ideas. I like the thinkers; idea guys.
After all, you can learn to write better prose. You can't learn how to imagine... That's a gift.
I sometimes wonder if book writing is really my calling, given my interests. Maybe I would be a better screen writer? Maybe I should write for comics? Or maybe video games? I guess if given the opportunity, I would be happy to give any of those options a try.
Is it all about beautiful prose?
To me, there is nothing more moving than a song with beautiful lyrics. You know as well as I do that there are great songwriters and then there are people who will use ridiculous words simply because they rhyme. Sometimes, they use the same word twice in a row because they can't find one that rhymes. Have you ever noticed that?
Beautiful music is one thing, beautiful poetry takes it to a whole other level. At least, to me.
My favorite songwriters are the likes of:
Florence Welch (Florence and the Machine)
Chris Cornell (Soundgarden, Audioslave, Temple of the Dog)
Roger Hodgson (Supertramp)
Fiona Apple
Fleetwood Mac (Lindsay Buckingham and Stevie Nicks)
There is certainly something to be said for beautiful prose.
But, is it everything?
Some will say that it is. Writers who can wax poetic like that are the epitome of great writers.
But, what about the story? How about what it takes to pull stories like Star Wars out of thin air? Just as there is something to be said for word usage, there is also something to be said for imagination.
I idolize the writers who write stories that take place in another time or on a different world or in another dimension. The art of creating something completely original is where it's at! I was so blown away by the movie The Matrix because the idea was so original. It was so fresh and so unlike anything I had ever seen before. I love that!
Personally, I happen to be far more entertained by a story that is unique and imaginative than I am by a story that is mediocre and predictable but beautifully written.
So, what makes someone a great writer? Is it someone who can think up amazing ideas and plot lines? Or is it someone who can string together words in beautiful fashion? I guess the perfect writer would be both. But, how often could that possibly happen?
Perhaps I am trying to compare apples to oranges. Maybe you can't compare the two because they are completely different aspects of writing. That's entirely possible. But, I happen to think the best writers are the ones who come up with the new ideas. I like the thinkers; idea guys.
After all, you can learn to write better prose. You can't learn how to imagine... That's a gift.
I sometimes wonder if book writing is really my calling, given my interests. Maybe I would be a better screen writer? Maybe I should write for comics? Or maybe video games? I guess if given the opportunity, I would be happy to give any of those options a try.
What do you think it takes to make someone a great writer?
I'm not really sure what it takes to make someone a great writer. Most of the prolific writers are gone and dead, so it may be something that can only be figured out years later.
ReplyDeleteMy criteria for great writing has usually been this.
ReplyDelete1. The writer has something to say.
2. The writer communicates it in a unique voice with prose that serves/enhances the story and gives insight into the characters mind and behavior (I give some leeway for self indulgence if it's an absurdist book).
3. The writer creates memorable characters and scenarios that are worth caring about.