This post contains spoilers about the movie "Young Adult" starring Charlize Theron. Just a little FYI.
Have you ever read a book or watched a movie where the main character was utterly despicable? Have you ever encountered an unlikable lead? I have, and it's weird. Usually, we want to root for the main character. They are supposed to be the hero, after all. It's nice if they have issues but also have some redeeming qualities. What happens when they don't? At the very least, shouldn't there be a character arc where they see their faults and the error of their ways and maybe try to better the situation? Is it wise to write stories around these types of main characters?
Take for example the movie Young Adult. I watched it over the weekend because... well, because it is about a chick who writes YA. Hello! So does --> This girl <--. It was a little different than I expected.
*SPOILERS*
Mavis (played by Charlize Theron) is a divorced ghost writer for a successful series of teen books that seem to be centered around an ultra-popular female high school student.
Mavis is suffering from depression and goes home from Minneapolis to her tiny hometown to try and reclaim her high school boyfriend from whom she received a birth announcement via email. This old flame is happily married, but Mavis decides that she is destined to be with him and does everything in her power to try and steal him from his wife. He's not interested in leaving his wife for her.
It quickly becomes clear that this ultra-popular high school girl that Mavis writes about is actually her. She was that girl in high school. But, she is struggling with the fact that her popularity didn't transcend into the real world. (Imagine that).
This character does some pretty pathetic things and she doesn't see just how morally bankrupt she is (even when the high school dork tries to point it out to her several times). It's a dark movie and not at all what I had expected. The only character arc that occurs is that she realizes it's not going to happen with this old flame and she goes back to Minneapolis. That's it. She doesn't really come to terms with her issues, except to air her dirty laundry during a meltdown at a baby shower. I expected more. I was waiting for her to see that being a home-wrecker is wrong. I wanted her to realize that she was being selfish. She didn't. She went home defeated. How sad. She never grew. She never arced.
I felt bad for the character, but I also despised her. She was so shallow! She was downright pathetic. I was a little put off when I finished the movie.
That got me thinking... Because, I have a book started that has a main character with questionable judgement. She's a selfish brat. But, the whole plot of the story is about her growth and maturity. It's about how she turns things around. (That character arc I mentioned). That's what Young Adult was missing.
Have you encountered a main character that you didn't like? Did you finish the book or movie? How do you feel about the idea of unlikable main characters?
Have you ever read a book or watched a movie where the main character was utterly despicable? Have you ever encountered an unlikable lead? I have, and it's weird. Usually, we want to root for the main character. They are supposed to be the hero, after all. It's nice if they have issues but also have some redeeming qualities. What happens when they don't? At the very least, shouldn't there be a character arc where they see their faults and the error of their ways and maybe try to better the situation? Is it wise to write stories around these types of main characters?
Take for example the movie Young Adult. I watched it over the weekend because... well, because it is about a chick who writes YA. Hello! So does --> This girl <--. It was a little different than I expected.
*SPOILERS*
Mavis (played by Charlize Theron) is a divorced ghost writer for a successful series of teen books that seem to be centered around an ultra-popular female high school student.
Mavis is suffering from depression and goes home from Minneapolis to her tiny hometown to try and reclaim her high school boyfriend from whom she received a birth announcement via email. This old flame is happily married, but Mavis decides that she is destined to be with him and does everything in her power to try and steal him from his wife. He's not interested in leaving his wife for her.
It quickly becomes clear that this ultra-popular high school girl that Mavis writes about is actually her. She was that girl in high school. But, she is struggling with the fact that her popularity didn't transcend into the real world. (Imagine that).
This character does some pretty pathetic things and she doesn't see just how morally bankrupt she is (even when the high school dork tries to point it out to her several times). It's a dark movie and not at all what I had expected. The only character arc that occurs is that she realizes it's not going to happen with this old flame and she goes back to Minneapolis. That's it. She doesn't really come to terms with her issues, except to air her dirty laundry during a meltdown at a baby shower. I expected more. I was waiting for her to see that being a home-wrecker is wrong. I wanted her to realize that she was being selfish. She didn't. She went home defeated. How sad. She never grew. She never arced.
I felt bad for the character, but I also despised her. She was so shallow! She was downright pathetic. I was a little put off when I finished the movie.
That got me thinking... Because, I have a book started that has a main character with questionable judgement. She's a selfish brat. But, the whole plot of the story is about her growth and maturity. It's about how she turns things around. (That character arc I mentioned). That's what Young Adult was missing.
Have you encountered a main character that you didn't like? Did you finish the book or movie? How do you feel about the idea of unlikable main characters?
It has to be done a certain way to work. Even Billy Bob's character Arced. He felt bad for that dumpy little boy and tried his best to be a mentor.
ReplyDelete