I just have to vent something really quick. As a woman and the mother of a girl who will soon be a woman, women's issues are at the forefront of my attention these days. In recent weeks, there have been two really big stories in the news on this topic. They are everywhere! I just happened to notice that they directly contradict one another and I want to draw the comparison even if nobody else ever reads this.
Story #1 involves the transgender bathroom laws.
There are a large number of men who are up in arms about the issue of transgender people being allowed to use the restroom that coincides with their gender identity. They claim to fear for the safety of women and girls with "grown men" coming into their safe haven that is the ladies room. Target department stores have been the epicenter of the controversy, as they have a bathroom policy allowing this. Some men have taken it upon themselves to stand guard outside the restroom to monitor who comes and goes from the ladies room. Evidently it's not the transgender folks they are worried about, but the loophole it creates (stupid, I know) for predators to enter without consequence.
Since women are so fragile and dainty and vulnerable, it is apparently extremely important that we all be protected from any would-be attackers by other brave men. The safety of women and girls is the main concern, after all. It's the number one priority! They don't want bad men endangering their mothers, daughters and sisters.
That's why story #2 is so confusing to me.
See, story #2 involves a former Stanford swim team standout named Brock Turner. This young Caucasian man has been convicted of raping a female student behind a dumpster while she was passed out after having too much to drink. He was spotted by two other guys who happened by the area. They stopped him and subdued him until police arrived.
The major issue in this story isn't even the disgusting crime he committed. The main problem is that the man's father wrote a letter to the presiding judge begging for leniency. The letter asked that this young man not be punished harshly for what he called, "20 minutes of action," because as a privileged white boy and a talented student athlete, prison was no place for him. The judge agreed, sentencing him to six months in jail followed by probation.
The rapist's father and the judge both felt that his well being was more important than the lifelong turmoil the victim will endure.
The internet is ripe with men commenting on this story with things like:
Okay, wait a second. I thought the main concern was the safety and protection of vulnerable women from predators? If that's the case, then how can folks place the blame of a rape on the unconscious victim?
It is because of situations like this that girls are taught that we need to be careful where we go, how we dress, that we never walk anywhere alone at night, never leave a drink unattended, because if we do, we are inviting an attack. As if all men are rapist lying in wait to attack us behind a dumpster. We are taught that men cannot be expected to control their urges and impulses. We are told that to avoid being sexually assaulted, we have to keep from provoking men. They are only men, after all and boys will be boys.
This is extremely problematic for a few reasons.
Number one, there are plenty of men out there who are not and never will be rapists. They could walk right past a scantily clad woman without even considering an attack against her! It's not fair to good men to paint them all as predators, as if it is just their nature and out of their control. If that were the case, those good Samaritans wouldn't have stopped Turner from raping that girl. They would have gotten in line. But, that seems to be the case with Brock Turner. His father tried to explain it away like, "Oh, you know how boys are..." Unfortunately, the judge agreed.
Number two, as far as Turner's acts being those of indiscretion. I'm sorry, but rape is not a mistake someone makes. You can't accidentally rape someone. It's not possible. Rape is a violent crime. It's not something that, "just happens."
The other point I want to reiterate is the whole, "We have to protect the women," thing. How can some men preach on the need for them to be our knights in shining armor because our safety is paramount and then turn around and explain how the victim of Brock Turner provoked her own attack. You can't claim to be a protector of women from would-be predators and then turn around and chastise an actual victim of an actual predator by claiming she brought it on herself, because... what do you expect? If I have too much to drink, you know what I expect? A hangover.
Here's a little personal anecdote. One night, a few years back, after meeting my best friend and her family at a restaurant for dinner I made a quick stop at a local watering hole. I wanted to stop for a beer with my cousins. I knew they would be there. They were ALWAYS there. Vic wasn't with me, I think he was working nights. But, I didn't think anything of it. It was the local bar, after all. Totally harmless. My cousins and I had a beer. We went out and danced to a couple of great pop songs. Soon, I noticed a guy dancing near me. He was a regular Billy-Bob redneck looking guy. He kept trying to move closer to me and I kept backing away. His attempts to get close to me were making me very uncomfortable. He was giving off a really strong creeper vibe.
I went back to the table where our longnecks were sitting and a different guy, a neck tattooed little scrawny thing in a wife beater tank top came up and told me that his friend wanted to get with me. I looked over at Billy Bob and he was still dancing, but was staring right at me. "I'm married and I have kids," I said, showing him my ring finger. "No thanks, I'm good." Scrawny neck tattoo's reply was so vulgar that I cannot type it here nor will I ever say it out loud. But, suffice it to say, he conveyed that his friend Billy Bob was not interested in taking no for an answer and told me exactly what he intended to do if I just followed him out to his car. I bluntly told him again that I was not interested.
The next think I new, I was being whisked out the door by my male cousin and we were followed out by the bartender. They walked me straight to my car and told me to leave. They were going to make sure I wasn't followed. I haven't gone back to a bar without Vic since that day. Lesson learned.
Did I do anything to provoke this? Was it my outfit? I mean, I was wearing an ethanol plant t-shirt and jeans. Was I dancing too seductively? I did say I was there with my family, didn't I? I had only had one beer, so I know it wasn't because I was too drunk. What did I do to provoke this seemingly average male? Nothing. This was his problem, as is the case with all creeps. It's them, not us.
Are we protecting women or are we not?
It seems like some men are only interested in protecting those mothers, daughters and sisters I mentioned earlier. All other women are on their own unless the illusion of protection is actually cover for a prejudice they have, as is the case with the Target uproar.
This is why it terrifies me to think about my independent, doe eyed wonderful daughter being turned loose on a college campus or out in the world in general. Instead of having to teach our girls to do everything in their power to avoid provoking their own rape, how about we teach our boys to keep their hand and dicks to themselves. They need to understand the definitions of respect and boundaries. There is no such thing as auto-consent.
Story #1 involves the transgender bathroom laws.
There are a large number of men who are up in arms about the issue of transgender people being allowed to use the restroom that coincides with their gender identity. They claim to fear for the safety of women and girls with "grown men" coming into their safe haven that is the ladies room. Target department stores have been the epicenter of the controversy, as they have a bathroom policy allowing this. Some men have taken it upon themselves to stand guard outside the restroom to monitor who comes and goes from the ladies room. Evidently it's not the transgender folks they are worried about, but the loophole it creates (stupid, I know) for predators to enter without consequence.
Since women are so fragile and dainty and vulnerable, it is apparently extremely important that we all be protected from any would-be attackers by other brave men. The safety of women and girls is the main concern, after all. It's the number one priority! They don't want bad men endangering their mothers, daughters and sisters.
That's why story #2 is so confusing to me.
See, story #2 involves a former Stanford swim team standout named Brock Turner. This young Caucasian man has been convicted of raping a female student behind a dumpster while she was passed out after having too much to drink. He was spotted by two other guys who happened by the area. They stopped him and subdued him until police arrived.
The major issue in this story isn't even the disgusting crime he committed. The main problem is that the man's father wrote a letter to the presiding judge begging for leniency. The letter asked that this young man not be punished harshly for what he called, "20 minutes of action," because as a privileged white boy and a talented student athlete, prison was no place for him. The judge agreed, sentencing him to six months in jail followed by probation.
The rapist's father and the judge both felt that his well being was more important than the lifelong turmoil the victim will endure.
The internet is ripe with men commenting on this story with things like:
- What do you expect when you get blacked-out drunk!?
- Stupid bitch was asking for it by drinking too much. As far as I'm concerned, she auto-consented by getting that drunk.
- A woman like that has no one to blame but herself.
Okay, wait a second. I thought the main concern was the safety and protection of vulnerable women from predators? If that's the case, then how can folks place the blame of a rape on the unconscious victim?
It is because of situations like this that girls are taught that we need to be careful where we go, how we dress, that we never walk anywhere alone at night, never leave a drink unattended, because if we do, we are inviting an attack. As if all men are rapist lying in wait to attack us behind a dumpster. We are taught that men cannot be expected to control their urges and impulses. We are told that to avoid being sexually assaulted, we have to keep from provoking men. They are only men, after all and boys will be boys.
This is extremely problematic for a few reasons.
Number one, there are plenty of men out there who are not and never will be rapists. They could walk right past a scantily clad woman without even considering an attack against her! It's not fair to good men to paint them all as predators, as if it is just their nature and out of their control. If that were the case, those good Samaritans wouldn't have stopped Turner from raping that girl. They would have gotten in line. But, that seems to be the case with Brock Turner. His father tried to explain it away like, "Oh, you know how boys are..." Unfortunately, the judge agreed.
Number two, as far as Turner's acts being those of indiscretion. I'm sorry, but rape is not a mistake someone makes. You can't accidentally rape someone. It's not possible. Rape is a violent crime. It's not something that, "just happens."
The other point I want to reiterate is the whole, "We have to protect the women," thing. How can some men preach on the need for them to be our knights in shining armor because our safety is paramount and then turn around and explain how the victim of Brock Turner provoked her own attack. You can't claim to be a protector of women from would-be predators and then turn around and chastise an actual victim of an actual predator by claiming she brought it on herself, because... what do you expect? If I have too much to drink, you know what I expect? A hangover.
Here's a little personal anecdote. One night, a few years back, after meeting my best friend and her family at a restaurant for dinner I made a quick stop at a local watering hole. I wanted to stop for a beer with my cousins. I knew they would be there. They were ALWAYS there. Vic wasn't with me, I think he was working nights. But, I didn't think anything of it. It was the local bar, after all. Totally harmless. My cousins and I had a beer. We went out and danced to a couple of great pop songs. Soon, I noticed a guy dancing near me. He was a regular Billy-Bob redneck looking guy. He kept trying to move closer to me and I kept backing away. His attempts to get close to me were making me very uncomfortable. He was giving off a really strong creeper vibe.
I went back to the table where our longnecks were sitting and a different guy, a neck tattooed little scrawny thing in a wife beater tank top came up and told me that his friend wanted to get with me. I looked over at Billy Bob and he was still dancing, but was staring right at me. "I'm married and I have kids," I said, showing him my ring finger. "No thanks, I'm good." Scrawny neck tattoo's reply was so vulgar that I cannot type it here nor will I ever say it out loud. But, suffice it to say, he conveyed that his friend Billy Bob was not interested in taking no for an answer and told me exactly what he intended to do if I just followed him out to his car. I bluntly told him again that I was not interested.
The next think I new, I was being whisked out the door by my male cousin and we were followed out by the bartender. They walked me straight to my car and told me to leave. They were going to make sure I wasn't followed. I haven't gone back to a bar without Vic since that day. Lesson learned.
Did I do anything to provoke this? Was it my outfit? I mean, I was wearing an ethanol plant t-shirt and jeans. Was I dancing too seductively? I did say I was there with my family, didn't I? I had only had one beer, so I know it wasn't because I was too drunk. What did I do to provoke this seemingly average male? Nothing. This was his problem, as is the case with all creeps. It's them, not us.
Are we protecting women or are we not?
It seems like some men are only interested in protecting those mothers, daughters and sisters I mentioned earlier. All other women are on their own unless the illusion of protection is actually cover for a prejudice they have, as is the case with the Target uproar.
This is why it terrifies me to think about my independent, doe eyed wonderful daughter being turned loose on a college campus or out in the world in general. Instead of having to teach our girls to do everything in their power to avoid provoking their own rape, how about we teach our boys to keep their hand and dicks to themselves. They need to understand the definitions of respect and boundaries. There is no such thing as auto-consent.
Comments
Post a Comment