Like it or not, today is the day of the Indie Author.
And, your feelings about that statement depend upon which side of the fence you reside. For aspiring and self-published authors, the news is very promising. If you're a book lover, times have never been better for you. But, for publishing houses, agents, and traditionally published authors, it is a straight kick to the nuts. And, they are not happy about it.
The Huffington Post ran an article last week called, "Sticks & Stones: The Changing Politics of the Self Publishing Stigma," where they chronicled what is quickly becoming a nasty battle. If you want to read it click HERE.
Those who support Traditional Publishing as the only credible source of quality books have drawn their line in the sand it seems. The Huff article quoted a traditionally published author (who they kept anonymous) as saying self-published books are nothing but, "literary karaoke."
Really? Literary karaoke? I'm sorry, but being traditionally published, does not a Hemingway make. You want to throw out the "Literature" card? Then let me ask you something. Is Twilight a great literary work? What about The Hunger Games? Will that series be known as an example of classic literature in a few years? Hardly...
Hold on folks, because I am about to throw Fifty Shades of Grey under the bus, for the sake of argument.
I have nothing against E.L. James. She's a writer like me who is living out her dream. More power to her. But, are her books great works of literature? In my day, that was called SMUT. And that's what it is. Smut; plain and simple.
Did I sit and devour the series like so many other thirty-somethings? Nope. But, I downloaded a sample to my Kindle. I just wanted to to see, number one: what all the fuss was about, and number two: if the writing was as atrocious as I had heard. How bad was it?
Well, in the very first paragraph, James begins with a "standing in front of the mirror scene," which every author knows is cliche and a major no-no. From there, she goes on to say things like, "I roll my eyes in exasperation." I'm not even sure that's possible! She uses words like, "satchel," instead of purse or handbag, which are a dead giveaway that she's a British lady trying to write an American novel.
Ok, so I picked that apart... The reason I did is because this chick's writing is no better than mine. It's far worse than many talented Indies who's work I have enjoyed very much. E.L. James is certainly not the greatest writer ever, but her books sell. And, at the end of the day, that is the real issue here.
It's not that Indies are offering up mediocre books or that they are somehow doing readers a disservice by publishing sub-standard content. It's that the BIG DOGS don't like us getting into their Kool-Aid. They hate that we can sell a book for $2.99 and make a 70% profit. They hate it! It really has nothing to do with writing quality (obviously). It all has to do with the green stuff.
Traditional Publishing's high and mighty can build as big a wall they want and they can throw stones until the cows come home. But, the fact is, Indie authors are here to stay.
And, your feelings about that statement depend upon which side of the fence you reside. For aspiring and self-published authors, the news is very promising. If you're a book lover, times have never been better for you. But, for publishing houses, agents, and traditionally published authors, it is a straight kick to the nuts. And, they are not happy about it.
The Huffington Post ran an article last week called, "Sticks & Stones: The Changing Politics of the Self Publishing Stigma," where they chronicled what is quickly becoming a nasty battle. If you want to read it click HERE.
Those who support Traditional Publishing as the only credible source of quality books have drawn their line in the sand it seems. The Huff article quoted a traditionally published author (who they kept anonymous) as saying self-published books are nothing but, "literary karaoke."
Really? Literary karaoke? I'm sorry, but being traditionally published, does not a Hemingway make. You want to throw out the "Literature" card? Then let me ask you something. Is Twilight a great literary work? What about The Hunger Games? Will that series be known as an example of classic literature in a few years? Hardly...
Hold on folks, because I am about to throw Fifty Shades of Grey under the bus, for the sake of argument.
I have nothing against E.L. James. She's a writer like me who is living out her dream. More power to her. But, are her books great works of literature? In my day, that was called SMUT. And that's what it is. Smut; plain and simple.
Did I sit and devour the series like so many other thirty-somethings? Nope. But, I downloaded a sample to my Kindle. I just wanted to to see, number one: what all the fuss was about, and number two: if the writing was as atrocious as I had heard. How bad was it?
Well, in the very first paragraph, James begins with a "standing in front of the mirror scene," which every author knows is cliche and a major no-no. From there, she goes on to say things like, "I roll my eyes in exasperation." I'm not even sure that's possible! She uses words like, "satchel," instead of purse or handbag, which are a dead giveaway that she's a British lady trying to write an American novel.
Ok, so I picked that apart... The reason I did is because this chick's writing is no better than mine. It's far worse than many talented Indies who's work I have enjoyed very much. E.L. James is certainly not the greatest writer ever, but her books sell. And, at the end of the day, that is the real issue here.
It's not that Indies are offering up mediocre books or that they are somehow doing readers a disservice by publishing sub-standard content. It's that the BIG DOGS don't like us getting into their Kool-Aid. They hate that we can sell a book for $2.99 and make a 70% profit. They hate it! It really has nothing to do with writing quality (obviously). It all has to do with the green stuff.
Traditional Publishing's high and mighty can build as big a wall they want and they can throw stones until the cows come home. But, the fact is, Indie authors are here to stay.
Not only is it smut,but it's stolen smut. She retooled a fanfiction on twilight if I remember right. Why hasn't she been sued yet?
ReplyDeleteKeith, I have nothing against the lady. I just thought she was the perfect example of how just because something is picked up by a big publisher, doesn't guarantee a quality piece of work.
DeleteSo true and big publishers shouldn't complain because when an indie gets big, they try to get a slice of the pie. Amanda Hocking for example. She made a million on books that traditional publishers rejected and when they saw how well she was doing, they held out their plates and said "I'd like some too please." It's like they don't want to do the work and as soon as they see someone who has done the work, they jump on the person like rabid dogs.
ReplyDeleteWell for so long that's how things were done. Now there is a new way that is different, that rewards the author and all they can think of is the easy money they are now losing. They keep it up, they will die. The smart publishers will adapt.
Delete